Skip to main content

Leadership Without Scars and Lived Experience

Young experts?

Every day on LinkedIn I am taught again what leadership is. How to become a great leader, which pitfalls to avoid, which five habits you need to be truly inspiring.

But when I look at the profiles of many of these writers, I see something strange: few years of experience, little real responsibility, yet perfectly polished texts. And since the rise of AI, they all sound more or less the same.

LinkedIn as a system has an appetite for yet another perfect post: well formatted, high reach, algorithm-friendly. But the people behind the screen need something else: authentic knowledge that has actually been lived, not just generated. Readers need real human beings who dare to say what they do and do not know.

Theory is not leadership

Everyone is allowed to think about leadership. Read, listen, observe – the more the better. But there is a difference between describing leadership and carrying leadership.

Leadership is not a matter of opinion. It is the sum of:

  • Years of responsibility
  • Mistakes and consequences
  • Nights lying awake
  • Getting back up again

You do not learn that from books alone, and certainly not from a handful of prompts.

You can write meaningfully about leadership if you have either led for a longer period of time yourself, or if you have spent many years in organizations carefully watching how things really work. Without that, you mostly recycle other people’s experience.

A person in their early twenties can definitely share interesting thoughts about leadership, but most of the time they are repeating what appears in books, podcasts, trainings – or what an AI model has just summarized for them.

The 23-year-old leadership expert

This is where it starts to chafe. A 23-year-old is absolutely allowed to post about leadership. In fact, I encourage it. But then be honest about where the content comes from:

  • “This is what I learned in my studies.”
  • “This is what I took from a book or podcast.”
  • “This is what I worked out with help from AI.”

It becomes unbelievable when someone at that age presents themselves as a seasoned leader or coach, as if there are 30 years of practice behind their words. Real experience has to be earned. You cannot prompt your way into scars.

Filling the content machine or having something to say

LinkedIn has become a content machine: be visible, post daily, build your personal brand. That pressure has consequences.

  • People write because there must be content, not because they really have something urgent to share.
  • AI fills the empty spaces: type “5 tips for authentic leadership” and a neat post appears within seconds.
  • The output is often presented as deeply personal wisdom, while it is mostly recycled material in a new layout.

A large share of longer thought-leadership posts is now AI-generated or heavily AI-assisted. That is why so many of them feel identical: same tone, same structure, same pseudo-depth.

The result is an endless layer of smooth but flat leadership talk. And even more noise on a channel that was already full.

Leadership requires scars

Real leaders have scars.

  • Decisions that turned out badly.
  • People they had to disappoint and then face in a real conversation.
  • Situations where they carried full responsibility, even when it was not “their fault”.
  • Moments where the bill for their choices landed straight on their own desk.

Scars come with doubt, shame, regret, growth, nuance. That does not fit well into a generic AI format. You can feel the difference between a lived story and a manufactured listicle.

We have known for years that there is a gap between leadership theory and leadership on the shop floor. Books and models provide language, but without responsibility the fine words are just an empty costume.

That is why it feels pointless to pollute LinkedIn even further with empty leadership talk: AI-texts without scars, tips without real accountability, coaches without years in the field.

AI is welcome, but not as a mask

I am not against AI. It is a useful assistant:

  • To structure knowledge
  • To develop ideas
  • To find words you did not have yet

But AI is no substitute for lived experience. And if AI writes a large part of your text, it helps to be open about that. More and more professionals argue for clear AI disclosure, precisely to protect trust.

In the same way, a young writer can simply say:

  • “I am just starting out; this is what I am learning from books, courses and AI.”

Instead of:

  • “Here is how you should do it as a leader,” as if decades of practice sit behind that sentence.

Young? Write. But ask questions.

Of course young people can write about leadership. They simply should not pretend to be the all-knowing coach.

If you have little experience, this is far more credible:

  • Write from curiosity instead of authority.
  • Name your sources: books, courses, people who inspire you, AI.
  • Ask questions to the people who have actually spent years at the helm.

Instead of ending a post with:

  • “What are your pitfalls?” – from a quasi-coaching position,

you can ask as a young professional:

  • “To everyone who has led for 10+ years: what do you wish you had known earlier?”
  • “Which mistake shaped you the most as a leader?”
  • “What is, in your experience, the biggest difference between leadership in books and leadership in real life?”

That is respectful, honest about where you stand yourself, and far more interesting to respond to.

What LinkedIn wants and what readers need

In short:

  • LinkedIn as a platform wants another perfect post: plenty of activity, reach and engagement.
  • Readers want real, lived-through knowledge and people who dare to say what they do and do not know.

People are getting tired of flat, AI-like mass-produced text. At the same time, authenticity is becoming more important, not less. Trust is built on real voices, not just on flawless formatting.

Maybe this is today’s real leadership exercise on LinkedIn:

  • Not writing yet another perfect post.
  • But daring to show where your limits and your scars are.

The rest is just content.


Comments