Sitting at the table
I am sitting at the table with someone I could call an “acquaintance”, but tonight it is more than that. Her words finally begin to break open. Problems, grief, disappointments – it all comes out. And that is good. Things are being spoken, things are being aired. We listen. We do not ask. We do not judge.
At a certain point, the room falls quiet. She picks up her phone and says she wants to listen to some music. Portuguese music, of course. The first notes fill the room and from a single line I already know enough: this is music about sadness, loss and misery. The soundtrack of pain.
I let it play for a moment, I listen along, and then I ask her one simple question:
“Why are you listening to sadness and misery?”
She looks at me, a little surprised.
“Yes, but the lyrics are about life,” she says.
I nod. “Yes. About the misery and the sorrow of life. But you already know that misery. You are living it now. Why would you listen to it again? You already know.”
She gives a crooked little smile.
“Yes, but I like to hear it.”
That is where the core lies for me.
When comfort turns into repetition
We say we are looking for comfort in music. That it is about recognition, feeling understood, “I am not alone”. And that is true. Music can be a soft blanket over raw feelings. A place where your sadness is allowed to exist for a moment, without anyone downplaying it.
But somewhere there is also a threshold. The moment where comfort turns into chewing the same thing over and over again. Where the music no longer helps you release anything, but keeps you stuck in the same loop of misery.
You are already living the pain.
You already know the story.
You are right in the middle of it.
So what makes us still voluntarily reach for the same lyrics, the same tone, the same drama? How often do we put our own life on repeat without noticing it?
A warm heart, misused too often
She is a social person, with her heart in the right place. The kind of person who listens to everyone and empathises with everyone. Someone who would walk through fire for others, who laughs easily, who talks easily. And precisely because of that, she has often been misused and influenced in her life. Not because she is stupid, but because she puts her heart to work sooner than her boundaries.
As she sits across from me, I read her with ease. How much can I say without losing her, and how much do I leave unsaid so as not to make it even heavier for her? She is no less intelligent than anyone else – if anything, the opposite. But she focuses on the wrong things. On people who drain her. On stories that keep her small. On music that confirms her sadness instead of waking up her strength.
Because of that, her own intelligence is never fully used. She feels a lot, but she does not truly think for herself.
It is as if her attention is being rented out to everything that hurts her. Other people, circumstances, old patterns – they take control of her thoughts. And I sit there across from her and feel that tension in myself. I listen, but I do not ask questions. I put a few things softly on the table. Nothing more.
The delightful warm mud pool
I do not sit down with her in the delightful warm mud pool. I do not jump into her jacuzzi of misery.
You cannot decide for someone else to climb out of the mud pool, when that mud has started to feel like a kind of jacuzzi to that person: a delightful warm mud pool. Familiar, warm, predictable. Painful, but safe.
That is exactly what people around her have so often done: either they got into the mud with her, or they pushed her down into it. Pitying her or judging her. But rarely that one middle ground: staying at the edge, present, honest, with a hand reaching out – without disappearing yourself.
Family of the blood, family of the heart
As we talk, something else dawns on me. We are not “family” in the official sense of the word: no shared blood, no joint family gatherings, no family tree that ties us together. And yet here we are, on a Saturday afternoon, with coffee, music and open wounds on the table.
There is family of the blood, and there is family of the heart. Blood says something about where you come from. The heart says something about where you truly come home.
Family of the heart are the people with whom you dare to break without putting on a show. With whom your sadness is not “too much”, but also not endlessly confirmed. The people who sit next to you when your world collapses, but refuse to go under with you in the same warm mud pool.
With family of the blood, you can sit at the same table for years and still never truly meet each other. With family of the heart, you can know each other only briefly and still lay your soul on the table. Not because you have to, but because something in you feels: here it is safe enough to be honest.
Sitting at that table with her, that is exactly what I feel. She is “just” an acquaintance, and at the same time, this is exactly what family of the heart does: they show up, they listen, they do not run away from pain – and they still keep a boundary.
Because real family of the heart does not say:
“Come on, I will jump into the mud with you, then at least we will be deep enough together.”
Real family of the heart says:
“I am staying with you, I will not let you fall. But I will not join you in your jacuzzi of misery. I will stand here at the edge, with my hand up, until you decide that you want to come out.”
You can sit beside someone, but you cannot stand up for them
People only come out of sadness, misery and depression if they want it themselves. You can sit beside them, but you cannot stand up for them. You can reach out a hand, you can listen, mirror, point to a different view. You can offer alternatives: different thoughts, different choices, different music if needed. But you are not the one who decides that the delightful warm mud pool has suddenly become too suffocating.
Maybe that is one of the hardest forms of love: not going down into the abyss, but standing at the edge with an open heart. Not forcing, not pulling. Only being available for the moment the other person decides: “Now I truly want to go up.”
Questions for your own playlist
So today I am not only asking these questions to her, but also to you – and to myself:
- Which pain do you voluntarily listen to, day after day?
- Which “favourite songs” in your life mostly confirm who you were yesterday?
- Is your sad music a soft blanket, or a chain?
- And who are your family of the heart – the people who stay next to you, but refuse to drown with you?
Maybe change does not begin with a big decision, but with one simple movement. To stop putting your misery on repeat. And to very gently, almost imperceptibly, put on a new song.

Comments
Post a Comment