When help hides truth
On LinkedIn I keep seeing lines like “I coach CEOs” and “I support senior leaders.” There is now a full industry built around “mentally supporting” people in top positions. And every time I see it, the same question comes up: if a role can only be sustained with constant support, what does that say about the person in the role – and about the system that put them there?
I do not believe we mainly have a “leadership crisis.” I believe we have a crisis of competence and integrity. In many executive teams, and especially in politics, people sit in positions where they do not fit, whether you look at skills, integrity, or emotional maturity. Not because the work is easy, but because the selection criteria are often wrong: visibility and positioning weigh more than actual suitability.
In that context, coaching too often becomes a neat way to avoid a very simple and uncomfortable truth: “This role does not fit this person, but we leave it as it is.”
Support is not the problem, lack of honesty is
I have no issue with people seeking support. A mirror, sharp questions, reflection: that belongs to professional adulthood. Wanting to understand yourself better and improve how you work is a strength, not a weakness.
But there is a fundamental difference between support used to grow in a role you can basically handle, and support used to keep you upright in a role you are not actually suited for. In that second case, the honest questions are no longer “Which coach do you have?” or “What program are you in?”, but much more direct ones like: “Should you be in this role at all?” or “Does this function in its current form make sense for one person?”
As long as those questions are not asked, coaching is at risk of becoming a distraction. It offers the feeling of movement, without touching the foundations that really matter: suitability, responsibility, and realistic design of functions.
Senior management: polished language, modest results
In senior management you see the same patterns every day. Decisions are postponed, responsibility is spread so thin that nobody really owns the outcome, and structural problems are pushed forward instead of addressed. The language is often polished and professional, the impact on people lower in the organisation is much less impressive.
When results clearly lag behind what the role requires, the logical step would be to say: “This person is not delivering what this function needs.” Instead, what often happens is the start of a new program: leadership tracks, executive coaching, offsites, personal development plans.
From the outside, this looks modern and caring. Internally, however, the simplest line is left unsaid: someone is not doing the job at the level the job actually demands. As long as that sentence is avoided, all the talk about “leadership development” remains half honest.
Politics: high responsibility, low suitability
In politics this becomes even more visible. Public trust in politicians is low, and not only because people disagree on policy. A big part of the distrust is about perceived lack of competence and reliability. My own sense is that a large majority of politicians would not pass if you soberly tested their role on three basic dimensions: skill, integrity, and consistency.
At the same time, entire teams of advisers, communication strategists, spin doctors and coaches work around them. A lot of effort goes into managing image and public performance. Far less energy goes into a few simple but essential questions:
- Can this person actually handle the content and complexity of the role?
- Does he or she carry responsibility in a way that truly fits the weight of the position?
- Is there a genuine willingness to face one’s own mistakes and limits?
Without honest testing on these points, most support remains cosmetic. It improves the appearance, not the substance. The gap between the role as it should be and the person as they are stays largely untouched.
Coaching as a social alibi
“I have a coach” sounds modern, reflective and responsible. It suggests effort and willingness to learn. In public discourse, it often functions as a sort of shield: if someone says they are “working on themselves”, it becomes harder to criticise them without sounding harsh.
But the sentence itself says nothing about actual suitability for a role. It does not restore missing integrity. It does not replace sound judgement, courage or the ability to step aside when that is what the role and the situation require.
Coaching can be a valuable tool. It becomes problematic when it turns into a social alibi: “Do not worry, I am working on myself,” while the concrete effects of poor decisions and weak leadership land on people who never chose that leader in the first place. In that case, coaching softens the discussion exactly where it should stay sharp.
When the function itself does not make sense
There is another layer that often gets ignored: sometimes the problem is not only the person, but the function itself. Some top roles are designed in a way that is barely realistic for a single human being. One person is supposed to carry vision, strategy, finances, media presence, internal culture, crisis management, stakeholder expectations and political games, all at once.
When you design a role like that, it is almost guaranteed that people will struggle, burn out, or slip into survival behaviour. That is not a sign of individual weakness; it is a sign that the role has become unrealistic. Still, instead of redesigning the function or splitting responsibilities, the default answer is often: more support, more coaching, more framing.
In those situations there are really only two honest options left. Either you admit that this individual is not the right person for a role of this scope. Or you admit that the role has become too big and diffuse, and it needs to be split, shared or redesigned into something a human being can realistically do.
The questions we rarely ask
If we want to move beyond appearances, we need to ask different questions. Not “Who is your coach?”, but questions like:
- Does this person demonstrably fit the responsibility and impact of the role?
- Does the system keep people in positions they are not fulfilling at the needed level?
- Is the role designed in a way that one person can carry it without constant crisis and compensation?
For public and political roles there is an extra layer:
- Are decisions visibly taken in the interest of society, or mainly in the interest of party, career or image?
As long as these questions are not openly asked and answered, the gap remains between the official description of a role and the actual behaviour of the person holding it. Coaching cannot close that gap if the surrounding system insists on looking the other way.
Less detours, more clarity
I have no objection to leaders who seek help. In many cases, that is a sign of seriousness. What I do object to is the way incompetence, poor fit and unrealistic functions are often wrapped in careful language about “development” and “coaching”, instead of being named and addressed directly.
Maybe it is time to put less emphasis on how many executives and politicians are “working on themselves”, and more emphasis on a few straightforward moves:
- Clearly saying when a person does not fit a role.
- Redesigning functions so that one person is not asked to carry an inhuman load.
- Recognising that support is useful, but never a substitute for actual suitability and integrity.
Only when we allow that level of honesty, coaching can return to what it was meant to be: a tool for people who are broadly in the right place and want to grow further, rather than a blanket covering systems that keep the wrong people in crucial seats.

Comments
Post a Comment