Skip to main content

The High Cost of “As If”: Why Fake Comfort Is Destroying Real Human Potential

The cult of “as if”

Humans are strange creatures. They buy fake gold watches because they look like real gold. They buy chipboard furniture with a thin layer of veneer because it looks like solid wood. They sit on vinyl sofas, roll artificial grass out on their balconies, wear plastic “lammy coats”, put on wigs that look like “real” hair. They drink alcohol-free beer because it almost tastes like the real thing, and buy fake meat and fake food because it “tastes the same” as real.

On top of that, they are now obsessed with AI for the same reason: it looks like intelligence and it sounds like intelligence.

A world built on “as if”

Look around and you will see that a large part of modern life is built on “as if”:

  • As if it is gold.
  • As if it is wood.
  • As if it is leather.
  • As if it is grass.
  • As if it is food.

Why?

Because people have come to believe that “as if” is cheaper, faster, easier to produce, easier to replace and, above all, good enough to fool the eye for a while.

People get used to the idea that appearance matters more than essence. If it shines like gold, who still cares what lies underneath? If the sofa looks like real leather in the photo, who still cares that in reality you are sweating on plastic?

Underneath it all, the same trade-off is always at work: effect over essence. “I want the effect, not the essence.” But in reality they do not even get the effect – only a brief flash that tricks the eye, usually the neighbour’s eye.

I do not play that game. I do not buy fake gold. I do not buy fake food.

A gold watch that was never really mine

In 1996 I bought a gold Cartier watch, the Pasha. For years, it was my dream watch. I could not wear it when speaking on stage, it was too valuable to take on holiday, I had to take it off when washing my car, and I could not wear it while gardening or doing odd jobs. The funny thing was this: whenever I did wear it and people saw the watch, they asked if it was real.

I sold it, and since then I have only worn steel watches. By the way, a “gold” watch is not 100% gold, it is an alloy; pure gold would be too soft to wear as a watch.

And now, with the AI hype, I am certainly not planning to treat my own intelligence as something that can be traded in for the cheapest “as if” version on the market.

From fake gold to fake living

Let’s be honest:

  • Fake gold is a way to wear the symbol of wealth without paying the price.
  • Veneered chipboard is a way to have the look of solid wood without the weight.
  • Vinyl is a way to have the look of a leather sofa without the price (and with a built-in sweat lodge in summer).
  • Artificial grass is a way to have something green without the trouble of real life, soil, insects and seasons.

The sound of a roaring 6- or 8-cylinder engine is being replaced by the almost silent hum of an electric drive. Even children’s toys, bikes, pedal cars and scooters come with little humming motors; even worse, because in that way children no longer learn to push, pedal or feel their own strength.

All of this is sold to us as progress – quieter, smoother, more efficient.

But every time we remove the need to push, to pedal, to feel speed in our bodies and power in our ears, we are not just changing the object. We are eating away at something in the human being behind it: coordination, courage, risk, play, presence, instinct.

That is not progress. That is the slow, comfortable destruction of human potential, disguised as convenience.

Fake food, fake fullness

Then there is fake and ultra-processed food: products designed to taste like something your body vaguely remembers, stripped of the real nutritional intelligence of nature.

Ultra-processed food is to nourishment what clickbait is to wisdom: fast, easy, addictive – and draining in the long run.

Fake lives, fake connection

And of course there is the fake life online: filtered faces, staged “authenticity”, carefully curated feeds that show a life no one actually lives. Friendship that looks more like “followers”. Depth that looks more like a performance.

All of it runs on the same underlying logic: “I want to look rich, connected, beautiful, healthy, meaningful – without the price, the effort, the risk, the time.”

Commerce benefits from isolated individuals; the human being does not.

Meanwhile, people love to throw around quotes like “enjoy life, it’s short”, “live as if there’s no tomorrow”, “live life to the fullest” – and they believe they are living that way. People preach life as a race to cram in as many experiences, purchases, trips and selfies as possible.

But what most do not realise is this: if you treat “you only live once” as a licence for quantity, as a substitute for quality, you end up with a life full of moments that never really touch you.

“Life is not measured by the number of breaths we take, but by the moments that take our breath away.” (often attributed to Maya Angelou).

The point is not to stack up even more moments, but to let a few real moments actually reach you. It is not the quantity of dinners, dates, parties, cities and gadgets that truly fulfils a human being, but the quality of a few real ones.

Quality calms your nervous system, grounds you, nourishes you; quantity of questionable quality keeps you agitated and empty at the same time.

Fake thinking as the newest layer

In that context, AI is simply the latest layer of “as if”. A system trained on mountains of human text and images until it can imitate how humans talk, write and reason. It does not feel, it has no body, no lived life – but it sounds as if it does.

For many people, that is enough. It looks like thinking, it sounds like thinking, so it must be thinking.

  • Fake gold.
  • Fake leather.
  • Fake grass.
  • Fake food.
  • Fake connection.
  • Fake thinking.

The problem is not that AI exists. The problem begins when people let it slowly replace real processes: real thinking, real feeling, real conversations, real learning.

Why I do not buy “real fake”

There is nothing wrong with tools. AI as a tool can be brilliant. Fake plants have their use. A processed snack on a long travel day is not a disaster. 

But fake as a way of life is a tragedy. I do not buy fake gold because I care more about essence than appearance. I do not buy fake food because I care more about how my body feels tomorrow than about how cheap and “convenient” something is today.

In the same way, I am not planning to outsource my own intelligence, my relationships or my choices to systems and surfaces that only look like the real thing. They do not know my body. They do not know my soul. They do not know my history. They do not know the field I plug into when I listen deeply.

They can help shape words and images. They can never take over responsibility for what those words and images carry energetically.

So yes, let anyone who wants to buy fake gold watches, vinyl sofas, plastic lammy coats, synthetic wigs, artificial grass and hyper-realistic fake food enjoy their "real fake" lives. Let them collect followers instead of friends and keep scrolling through lives staged for the camera.

But maybe, quietly, a different question can be asked:

If everything in your life is “as if” – as if it is gold, as if it is wood, as if it is friendship, as if it is wisdom, as if it is intelligence – which single “as if” choice are you willing to turn into something real today?


Comments