Authentic Competence
Anyone involved in learning, coaching or leadership comes across the classic model of the four stages of competence sooner or later: unconscious incompetence, conscious incompetence, conscious competence and unconscious competence. It is a clear framework that shows how we develop new skills, from "I do not know what I cannot do" to "I do it well without thinking about it".
In many trainings, unconscious competence is seen as the final destination: you have "arrived" because you do something well, automatically. But in practice – especially in speaking, leadership and coaching – there is a layer beyond that fourth stage, which I have come to call authentic competence.
The limits of unconscious competence
Unconscious competence is comfortable: you have routine, ease, automatic quality. Yet this phase has a shadow side. Someone who mostly operates on autopilot can find it difficult to explain how they do what they do, which becomes a problem when they want to train or coach others.
They can also slowly drift away from their values, audience or context, precisely because everything runs so smoothly. On stage or in leadership, you can recognise this in people who are technically strong, but still do not feel entirely real. Something is out of alignment between the inside and the outside.
What is authentic competence?
For me, authentic competence is the phase after unconscious competence. It is the combination of:
- Craftsmanship: you can really do it, even under pressure
- Awareness: you see yourself in action and can explain what you do and why
- Authenticity: your behaviour is aligned with your values, your story and the people in front of you
An authentically competent speaker or leader is not just performing a trick, but is present as a human being. The technique is integrated, but connection is central.
Example 1: Three broken projectors
One moment in which I experienced this very concretely as a speaker was during a presentation where the technology failed one thing after another. The lamp of the overhead projector blew while I was speaking. A spare projector was brought in – which also failed shortly afterwards. A little later a third projector arrived, borrowed from another room in the venue.
Instead of freezing or stopping, I stayed in contact with the audience and explained where I was in the presentation: at the point where I was about to introduce our product. So I told them – with a smile – that we sold projectors. The audience laughed, the tension dropped, and that moment in particular made people experience me as authentic.
Example 2: A curtain of water
Another moment where authentic leadership became visible was during a presentation in a room with a glass roof. Above the stage, tarps had been placed over the glass to block the daylight so the projection screen would remain visible. When a heavy rainstorm broke out, it turned out that the drains were blocked by those tarps: suddenly a curtain of water came down between the stage and the first row.
While another speaker was on stage, I jumped up, asked everyone to move to another room for their safety and invited them to have a drink there at my expense. Together with the hotel staff and several of my managers, we spent about half an hour mopping and removing the water with buckets. The room became usable again, even though the carpet was completely soaked.
After that, I took over the presentation, briefly apologised and then simply continued with the next part – without going back to what had not been fully covered before. In moments like these, you can really sense whether you are only technically competent, or also authentically competent: present, decisive and connected to the people in the room.
How to develop the fifth phase
The step from unconscious competence to authentic competence does not require new tricks, but a different attitude.
- Reflection: regularly looking back at your actions. When were you real? When were you acting a role?
- Feedback: inviting people to respond not only to your "performance", but also to how it felt and how congruent it was.
- Slowing down: not doing everything on autopilot, but sometimes deliberately slowing down to feel again what you do and why.
Why this fifth phase matters now
In a time of AI, scripts, templates and polished online profiles, being good at your job is becoming less and less distinctive. What truly touches people is not just competence, but congruent, tangible realness.
Being authentically competent means using your talent and experience in a way that fits who you are – visible, explainable and shareable, so that others can learn from it as well.
Questions for your own journey
- In which of the four classic stages do you recognise yourself most often right now: unconscious incompetence, conscious incompetence, conscious competence or unconscious competence? And in which situations?
- Can you remember a moment when something went wrong (a question, interruption or technical problem) and you still managed to stay present and yourself? What did that reveal about your level of competence?
- Where do you notice that you sometimes hide behind routine or "tricks", instead of showing your real self, doubts or humour in the moment? What would authentically competent look like there for you?
- Which skill or role in your life is ready to move from "unconscious competence" to "authentic competence" – not just doing it well, but doing it in line with your values and the people you serve?
If any part of this resonates with you, you are warmly invited to pick one of these questions and share your answer. Your reflection might help someone else recognise where they are now – and what their own next step toward authentic competence could be.

Comments
Post a Comment